American Bible Challenge and It Takes a Church are not leaving GSN anytime soon, I predict.
With my prediction, American Bible Challenge will have a 9-episode order for its fourth season. It Takes a Church will have a 6 to 8 episode second season order. Both of these would not air until after the New Year.
Since the May 22nd season premiere, American Bible Challenge has averaged 544,000 viewers (7 episodes) while It Takes a Church has averaged 401,000 viewers (4 episodes) since its June 5th premiere. This is in comparison to GSN's primetime average of 326,000 total viewers (Monday through Sunday, 8pm to 11pm ET). By those statistics, there is no doubt that, looking this early, Bible and Church will get additional seasons.
Game Show Network seems to be very happy with the numbers anyway: